Whether it’s linked to a case of whistleblowing, a problematic work culture or discrimination, the decision to sue an employer is never easy. For some compliance officers, however, there may come a point in which legal action is the only recourse available to them to expose wrongdoing, protect their professional reputation or stand up for their rights.
But how do you know when you’ve reached that point, and what should you do next?
Know your rights
“It is not uncommon for financial services professionals to be victims of unlawful discrimination by their employer or colleagues—for example, sex, race or age discrimination. A typical scenario is when a woman returns after maternity and finds their clients and job scope severely reduced,” says Ged Nichols, general secretary of Accord, an independent UK-based specialist trade union for financial services staff.
This is precisely what happened to Jagruti Rajput, a senior compliance officer at Commerzbank in London. In October 2018, Ms. Rajput won her case against the bank for sex and maternity discrimination. The court ruled that the bank had failed to fairly consider her for a promotion, and had used her maternity leave as an opportunity to pass on significant elements of her job to a colleague.
Another recent lawsuit by an employee against Commerzbank was less successful. Najam Khan, the bank’s former head of corporate finance and Middle East Islamic finance in Dubai, claimed that during his time with Commerzbank he was told to “shut up” about compliance issues, harassed and eventually fired for reporting his concerns about failures to adequately separate the private and public sides of the business.
“Financial services professionals may also well see wrongdoing in the organisation and as a result ‘blow the whistle’. If the individual is then treated worse—for example is dismissed because they blew the whistle—they will have a whistleblowing claim which is potentially valuable with uncapped compensation,” says Nichols.
Whistleblowing law is complicated
It is important for employees to gather as much information about their legal rights before taking any action, according to Nichols. In cases that stem from exposing wrongdoing, employees should first ensure that their potential complaint will be covered under protections for whistleblowers.
Mr. Khan ultimately dropped his whistleblowing case against Commerzbank and agreed to pay a share of Commerzbank’s legal costs.
Wendy Addison, CEO and founder of SpeakOut SpeakUp Ltd and a whistleblower herself, agrees that it is crucial to seek legal advice as early as possible.
It’s also very important for employees reporting suspected wrongdoing to be clear about whether they are reporting formally or informally, Addison explains.
Going to court should be a last resort
Would-be litigants should also keep in mind that most companies will be able to mount a strong defence to any lawsuit, in part because of the potential reputational and monetary costs they can incur from court rulings, according to Nichols.
Where possible, employees should try to settle a case and avoid going to court altogether, according to Addison.
According to Nichols, factors that employees should take into account before initiating legal action against their employer include:
- Time limits: Some claims need to be presented within a specific time period. If that time period has expired, seeking legal redress is likely to be very difficult and may not ultimately succeed.
- Eligibility: Employees should also check that they have the requisite length of service to bring the claim that they wish to pursue. Some claims, such as ordinary unfair dismissal, require the employee to have been employed for two years before they are eligible to bring the claim.
- Cost: Bringing a legal case can be incredibly expensive, especially if the case is prolonged and/or complex. Employees should carefully consider how to fund their legal action, including planning for a worst-case scenario in which the suit may be dragged out over a long period of time.
If you do end up having to take a case to court, however, Addison has some practical advice.
It’s also important to request all historic job appraisals from HR, according to Addision.
Above all, she says, “be prepared for a tough ride.”
Melbourne-based Elise Thomas has a background in international affairs and a strong interest in financial crime, data and technology issues.
Drawing on deep subject matter expertise and our many customer and partner relationships globally we deliver valuable insights through weekly KYC newsletters, white papers, podcasts and events.Explore the Knowledge Hub
Exclusive event with former F1 Head of Race Strategy
Mastering Compliance Process Transformation - Lessons from the frontline